Pages

Friday, December 21, 2012

Does this make me a bad person?

So for the past 6 months I have attempted to get healthier.  I have in general been eating better, but I'm pretty terrible at denying myself things, so instead of giving myself a really hard time because a bear claw at Panera was calling to me, I will eat half of it one day, half the next, and run a bunch of miles in between.  Less denial, more miles.  I just came up with that and I'm pretty proud of it.

I never thought I'd get to the point where I actually need to replace my running shoes because I beat them up, but it feels pretty good.  I'm gonna treat myself and find a specialty running shop and let them measure my feet and whatever weird voodoo they need to make happen so I get really awesome shoes.  I hope they are neon.

I've basically had three goals since starting this change.

1. Be healthy
2. Log more miles
3. Drop some pounds

Yes, goal 3 is mostly because if I'm lighter I can run more and faster, but I have started to wonder if wanting to lose weight is anti-feminist, fatshaming, or something else awful.  I've dropped about 25 pounds since I started this, but I don't want it to be at the expense of being body-positive.

I know I'm in pretty decent shape.  I am not fast, at all, when I run, but my long workouts are creeping up towards 5 miles and I know I couldn't have done that 7 months ago.  Ice cream happens, but fruit and vegetables and eating when I'm hungry instead of bored happens more.  I'm down a jeans size, which was cool but more so because I now have pants that fit me.  Pants that fit are like the 8th wonder of the world.

But then I start to think about the entire concept of weight as a measurement of health, and then I hate myself for wanting to lose anything.  I should be measuring my overall health, and if I need to look at numbers, I should be checking my mile log to see if that's going up, not the scale to see if it's going down.  At my last doctor's appointment, I got irrationally angry once I got in the car because the doctor had told me "I'd like to see you lose a little weight" after I'd told him that I run 3-4 times a week, my blood pressure and pulse rate were awesome, I eat fine, I don't smoke, and so on and so forth.  The number on the scale was more important.
 
I've since figured out that my concern over weight loss can be split into two camps: one, pounds are generally a pretty shitty way of determining whether someone is healthy, and two, no matter what anyone says, skinny is still the beauty standard for America and extra pounds means you're gonna get fatshamed.

First camp, whatever.  I'll get angry about it sometimes (see above doctor conversation), but I know I'm healthy and getting healthier, so haters gonna hate.  I don't weight myself often, so I know I'm not obsessed with dropping pounds, and overall, whatever, I'm allowed to notice weight loss.  But the second camp?  I can't come to terms with it at all.
  
The country hates fat people, and fat women in particular.  Women are allowed (and encouraged, as if this were something we could control) to have "curves," which means breasts and an ass but nothing else.  Extra pounds means you're lazy and ugly.  Lines like "they shouldn't make leggings in sizes bigger than a medium" is treated as Pulizter-prize-winning wit instead of the cruel bullshit that it is. 

I'm still generally shy and embarrassed when I go to the gym, and that's really not okay.  I paid to be there and I wipe machines off after I use them and frankly that is all that should matter.  I am constantly convinced, however, that people are looking at me and judging me because I'm not a size 2 and I'm using a treadmill.  I live in fear that after a spin class some misguided lady is gonna come up to me and say "good for you getting through this class!"  This is a paraphrase of an article I read, but this basically sums it up: pretty much everyone at a gym is there for the express reason of not being me.  No one signs up for a year-long membership hoping to walk out looking like I do.

So does wanting to be skinnier (albeit mostly because I will be able to run faster and more) make me a bad person?  Am I buying into the bullshit?  Am I letting myself feel unattractive to the world until I'm down a few more sizes? 

Thoughts and advice?

2 comments:

  1. You're an inspiration to women everywhere. Too often we get hung up on a number and to what end? No matter how hard some people try they will never be a Size 2. In my case, it's physically impossible unless I am a skeleton.

    Eating healthier and exercising more, you are bound to lose a few pounds. It doesn't make you a bad person to want to feel good. The important thing to focus on is being comfortable in your own skin.

    So don't think skinny, think strong.

    ReplyDelete
  2. placing our perceptions and actions in a greater social framework is a means to an end (feeling better about our lives). if the social theory isn't bringing anything into your life in some particular case then why worry about it?

    ReplyDelete